Old Brookville Homes for Sale

Welcome to Old Brookville, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Nassau County, New York. This picturesque village is renowned for its serene atmosphere, lush landscapes, and a strong sense of community. With its charming tree-lined streets and beautifully manicured properties, Old Brookville offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life while still being conveniently located just a short drive from Manhattan.

Old Brookville boasts a rich history and an array of amenities that cater to a sophisticated lifestyle. Residents enjoy access to top-rated schools, exclusive country clubs, and a variety of outdoor recreational activities. The village is home to stunning parks and nature preserves, providing ample opportunities for hiking, biking, and leisurely strolls. Whether you’re an outdoor enthusiast or simply looking to unwind in a peaceful setting, Old Brookville has something for everyone.

For those in search of a new home, Old Brookville offers an impressive selection of properties for sale. From sprawling estates with manicured lawns to charming family homes, the real estate market here caters to diverse tastes and lifestyles. Each home reflects a unique blend of elegance and comfort, often featuring spacious layouts, modern amenities, and exquisite architectural details.

As you explore the homes for sale in Old Brookville, you’ll discover a community that values privacy and luxury, making it the perfect place to call home. Experience the best of suburban living while being just moments away from the vibrant culture and excitement of New York City. Your dream home awaits in Old Brookville!

Newest Old Brookville Homes for Sale

$2,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1044302 MLS

5 Woodfield Lane! Set on beautiful landscaped grounds, this impressive residence offers a wonderful blend of space, comfort, and privacy. Totally renovated in 2019! A gracious entry welcomes you into expansive living areas with soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, Stone and hardwood floors, multiple gathering spaces designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious eat-in kitchen features extensive custom cabinetry, generous counter space, a large center island, and a wall of windows overlooking the lush property. The adjoining living and dining areas create an open, inviting flow, while two fireplaces add warmth and character to the home. The generously sized grounds provide a rare sense of privacy and tranquility, with mature landscaping, expansive lawns, and a private tennis court creating an exceptional outdoor setting. The long driveway provides a striking approach to the residence and ample space for guests. With its generous proportions, sophisticated architectural details, multiple living spaces, and extraordinary property, this residence offers a unique opportunity to enjoy an elegant home in a truly private setting. Finished basement features high ceilings, home office, gym, recreation room.

5 Woodfield Lane, Old Brookville

$3,500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1031287 MLS

Set on two level acres surrounded by mature trees in the sought-after Village of Old Brookville, this distinctive three-bedroom, three-bath residence offers a peaceful setting with expansive lawns and exceptional privacy. A long driveway provides abundant parking in addition to the attached two-car garage. Inside, the main level features a dramatic living room with approximately 16-foot ceilings, creating an open and impressive gathering space. Two fireplaces add warmth and character, while the flexible floor plan provides comfortable areas for everyday living, entertaining and working from home. The spacious primary suite includes a private loft that can serve as a home office, workout area or quiet retreat, along with a walk-in closet and generously sized full bathroom. Outside, a deck and adjoining patio provide inviting spaces for dining, entertaining or relaxing while overlooking the broad, level grounds and natural surroundings. Conveniently located within the North Shore School District, this Old Brookville property presents a rare combination of acreage, privacy, parking and versatile interior and outdoor living space, with an opportunity for the next owner to personalize the home to suit their individual vision.

1 Stonegate Lane, Old Brookville

$5,250,000

6 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 1031994 MLS

Beyond a long, tree-lined driveway, an exceptional brick Center Hall Colonial awaits on four private acres in prestigious Old Brookville. Defined by timeless architecture, grand proportions, and resort-caliber amenities, this extraordinary estate embodies the elegance, privacy, and refined lifestyle synonymous with Long Island’s Gold Coast. A dramatic two-story foyer with a sweeping staircase welcomes you into beautifully appointed interiors designed for both grand-scale entertaining and comfortable everyday living. The thoughtfully designed floor plan offers expansive formal and informal living spaces, including a gracious living room that flows seamlessly into the inviting den. At the heart of the home is an exceptional chef’s kitchen, thoughtfully designed with premium appliances, custom cabinetry, expansive workspace, and a generous center island. The kitchen opens effortlessly to the outdoor entertaining spaces, creating a seamless connection between indoor and outdoor living. Step outside to your own private resort, where multiple stone patios, a fully equipped outdoor kitchen, sparkling in-ground pool, and beautifully appointed pool house provide the ultimate setting for entertaining or quiet relaxation, all surrounded by meticulously landscaped grounds and unmatched privacy. The luxurious primary suite serves as a private retreat, complete with a large dressing room and a spa-inspired bath featuring a soaking tub, oversized shower, and refined finishes. Five additional spacious bedrooms, along with seven full bathrooms and three half bathrooms, provide exceptional accommodations. The finished lower level is designed for both recreation and relaxation, offering a custom wine cellar, state-of-the-art home theater, fitness center, expansive recreation room, and abundant storage. Perfectly blending timeless design with modern luxury, this remarkable estate offers an unparalleled lifestyle in one of Old Brookville’s most sought-after locations, where privacy, sophistication, and exceptional entertaining come together in a truly extraordinary setting.

33 Chicken Valley Road, Old Brookville

$13,600,000

10 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 1034316 MLS

Steeped in the grandeur of Long Island's celebrated Gold Coast, this extraordinary 15+ acre equestrian estate formally named 'Westward' presents a rare opportunity to acquire a significant piece of North Shore history. Privately nestled amid rolling pastures, mature woodlands, and formal gardens, the estate seamlessly blends timeless architectural elegance with an unparalleled country lifestyle just moments from New York City. Originally commissioned in 1924 for noted industrialist and financier Benjamin Brewster Jennings - President and Chairman of Socony-Mobil and a prominent figure in New York's financial and corporate circles - this Georgian Revival brick residence with a cascading slate roof was masterfully designed by renowned architect Walter B. Chambers. The estate's distinguished landscape plan was created by legendary landscape architect Ellen Biddle Shipman, whose formal gardens and thoughtfully designed grounds continue to define the property's enduring beauty. Approached by a long, tree-lined drive framed by classic stone walls, the stately residence commands a setting of exceptional privacy and serenity. Encompassing three full levels of living space, the home is distinguished by grand entertaining rooms, soaring proportions, multiple wood-burning fireplaces, graceful arched windows, leaded-glass details, and an abundance of natural light. A gracious entrance vestibule opens to a sweeping curved staircase, while expansive formal living and dining rooms provide an elegant backdrop for entertaining on any scale. The 10 bedroom, 9.5 bathroom primary residence also features a spacious eat-in kitchen, indoor spa pool, vast slate patios and an outdoor swimming pool with cabana set against picturesque grounds, providing an idyllic backdrop for outdoor enjoyment. For equestrian enthusiasts, the property offers a turnkey horse facility. The grounds include a well-maintained main barn, run-in sheds (equipped with stalls, water, and electricity), a hot walker, extensive paddocks, and open acreage ideal for riding and grazing. Additionally, this unmatched property includes charming gatehouse cottages, staff apartments, and multiple ancillary structures, most of which have been recently renovated, creating flexibility for guests, caretakers, or income-producing opportunities. Located within one of the North Shore's most prestigious and historically significant communities, the estate enjoys close proximity to Long Island Sound beaches, renowned equestrian facilities, and some of the region's finest private clubs and golf courses. Zoned within the esteemed North Shore Central School District. Rarely does a property of this caliber come to market - offering a remarkable combination of provenance, architectural distinction, equestrian amenities, acreage, and development potential. A legacy estate of exceptional character and enduring significance, representing the very essence of North Shore country living.

97 A Pound Hollow Road, Old Brookville

$6,999,000

7 Beds ⋅ 9 Baths ⋅ 1021590 MLS

Old Brookville | Welcome to 3 Valentine Farm Court, where timeless architecture, exceptional craftsmanship, and an unmatched collection of luxury amenities define one of the North Shore's most impressive private estates. Positioned behind double iron gates at the end of a secluded cul-de-sac, this stately brick center hall colonial is situated on more than three meticulously landscaped acres, combining remarkable privacy with an extraordinary level of recreation and entertaining amenities. The residence is introduced by a spectacular two-story domed foyer showcasing a sparkling chandelier, intricate hand-painted ceiling details, and extensive custom millwork carried throughout every level of the home. Formal and informal living spaces are thoughtfully arranged, including an expansive formal living room, richly appointed mahogany library, inviting family room with one of three wood-burning fireplaces, formal dining room, powder room, and a spacious first-floor en-suite bedroom with separate exterior access. The custom kitchen is appointed with premium gas appliances, custom cabinetry, a center island with seating, an adjoining breakfast area, and an expansive butler's pantry connecting directly to the formal dining room. Extending from the main level, an elevated terrace with a built-in outdoor kitchen overlooks the estate grounds and pool complex below. The second level features five bedroom suites, each with their own full bathroom. Occupying its own wing of the home, the primary suite includes a private balcony overlooking the property, separate sitting room, two oversized walk-in closets, and an expansive en-suite bathroom with dual vanities and a jetted soaking tub. Designed as an exceptional recreational and entertaining space, the lower level features a custom wet bar, expansive gathering areas, a fully equipped fitness center, additional bedroom and full bathroom, oversized laundry room, and a below-grade indoor sports court with min. 15-foot ceilings—a rarely available amenity in residential construction. The outdoor amenities are equally impressive. The resort-inspired grounds are centered around an oversized gunite swimming pool with an integrated spa and water features, surrounded by expansive patios and mature landscaping. A fully equipped pool house includes a full bathroom, laundry facilities, and an indoor kitchen with a built-in grill opening directly onto the pool terrace. Completing the estate is a full-size sports court configured for both tennis and basketball, along with an oversized three-car garage equipped with vehicle lifts offering additional space for the car enthusiast. Representing an exceptional combination of scale, craftsmanship, and amenities on more than three private acres, 3 Valentine Farm Court presents a rare opportunity within one of the North Shore's most distinguished settings.

3 Valentine Farm Court, Old Brookville

$2,499,999

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1019434 MLS

This extraordinary Old Brookville estate at 19 Pheasant Hill Lane, featured in Architectural Digest, is a rare Georgian inspired residence that embodies timeless architecture, exceptional craftsmanship, and refined design. Perfectly positioned on two flat, private acres along one of Old Brookville’s most peaceful and coveted streets, this 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath home offers elevated living within the award winning North Shore School District. A charming circular driveway welcomes you to the stately facade, where grand Georgian columns create an unforgettable first impression. Beyond the marble foyer, the home unfolds with elegant living spaces rich in character and architectural detail. Luxurious marble bathrooms, custom designer lighting throughout, and a spectacular all glass cupola that fills the home with natural light showcase the remarkable quality and craftsmanship found in every room. Designed for today's lifestyle, the thoughtfully planned layout includes a first-floor bedroom, ideal for guests, extended family, or a private home office. Every space reflects warmth, sophistication, and timeless appeal, creating a home that is both inviting and impressive. The fully finished lower level is an entertainer's dream unlike any other. Featuring an expansive restaurant style bar, a custom built nightclub inspired entertainment venue complete with a DJ booth, dance floor, and generous gathering areas, this one of a kind space is perfectly suited for hosting unforgettable celebrations and private events. Outside, the sprawling two acre property offers endless possibilities to create your own resort style backyard oasis. With ample room for a luxurious pool, spa, outdoor kitchen, tennis or pickleball court, and beautifully landscaped gardens, the grounds provide the perfect canvas for exceptional outdoor living. Ideally located just minutes from the charming villages, fine dining, boutique shopping, renowned country clubs, parks, and Long Island Rail Road stations, this exceptional residence offers the perfect balance of privacy, convenience, and prestige. A truly remarkable Architectural Digest featured estate where timeless elegance, extraordinary entertaining, and the coveted Old Brookville lifestyle come together in one exceptional offering.

19 Pheasant Hill Lane, Old Brookville

$4,795,999

11 Beds ⋅ 14 Baths ⋅ 1016829 MLS

A truly extraordinary opportunity to create one of Brookville's most distinguished private estates. Nestled on an expansive 15-acre parcel in the prestigious Village of Old Brookville, this remarkable property offers an unparalleled setting on one of the area's most coveted and desirable streets. Plans envision a magnificent 22,000-square-foot luxury residence thoughtfully designed to blend timeless elegance with modern sophistication. Surrounded by mature landscaping and serene natural beauty, the estate offers exceptional privacy while remaining conveniently located near renowned schools, country clubs, fine dining, and major transportation routes. A picturesque private pond serves as the centerpiece of the grounds, creating a tranquil and captivating backdrop for the future residence. The vast acreage presents limitless possibilities for world-class amenities, including formal gardens, resort-style outdoor living spaces, recreational facilities, and equestrian pursuits. Rarely does an offering of this caliber become available—a unique chance to build a legacy estate tailored to your vision in one of Long Island's most exclusive enclaves. An exceptional canvas upon which to create a truly iconic residence

1 Penny Pond Court, Old Brookville

$5,498,000

7 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 1009813 MLS

Nestled on approximately 5 landscaped acres in Old Brookville, this distinguished estate offers exceptional space, privacy, and classic Gold Coast character. The property includes a stately main residence, a separate 3-bedroom guest cottage, and a pool house, providing flexible living and entertaining opportunities. The main residence offers approximately 5,764 square feet of living space with 7 bedrooms, soaring ceilings, hardwood floors, and elegant French arched windows that bring abundant natural light throughout the home. Expansive interiors overlook manicured grounds, gardens, and open scenic views. Recently renovated bathrooms blend modern updates with timeless design, while generously sized living areas provide comfort and functionality. The beautifully maintained grounds showcase seasonal landscapes and mature plantings, creating a serene setting year-round. Accessed through a gated entrance and private drive, this exceptional estate presents a rare opportunity to own a significant property in the desirable Village of Old Brookville.

952 Cedar Swamp, Old Brookville

$5,499,000

9 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 1005247 MLS

Set on 3.32 meticulously landscaped acres, this sophisticated and elegant Gold Coast jewel is a true luxury retreat. The home was designed by esteemed early 20th-century architect Mott B. Schmidt, who was highly regarded for his grand homes. A grand entrance welcomes guests, framed by stately arched trees that line the long, circular driveway. Inside, the richly paneled foyer and wide pegged oak floors set the stage for exquisite architectural details, including a sweeping staircase and intricate custom millwork. The first floor offers a seamless blend of grandeur and comfort. The magnificent living room and banquet-sized dining room both feature elegant fireplaces, while the gourmet kitchen boasts a spacious center island and a bright breakfast room. A butler’s pantry adds convenience, and the library, adorned with built-in bookcases and a fireplace, offers a cozy retreat. Additional highlights include a sunroom, two en suite guest bedrooms, a first-floor washer/dryer, and a powder room. Oversized windows throughout the home provide breathtaking views of the lush grounds. The expansive primary suite is a private sanctuary, complete with a fireplace, spa-like bath, dressing area, and a large balcony overlooking the manicured gardens. This level also features four additional bedrooms with two Jack-and-Jill baths, two additional fireplaces, a gracious hall bath, a gym/bedroom, an office/bedroom, and a second-floor laundry room. The lower level offers an abundance of recreational space, including a playroom, arts and crafts area, and a full bath. The exquisitely landscaped grounds provide something for everyone, offering endless opportunities for relaxation and entertainment. The sunken gardens, originally designed by renowned landscape architect Robert Ludlow Fowler Jr., are a marvel to behold. They gracefully lead the way to a serene 20x50 saltwater gunite pool that is complemented by a spacious, elegant pool house. Sports enthusiasts will appreciate the lighted clay tennis court and a heated, enclosed outdoor structure, perfect for squash or basketball. Adding to the estate’s appeal, a charming three-bedroom, two-bath guest cottage provides comfortable accommodations, while a three-car heated garage with a separate workroom ensures ample space for vehicles and storage. This extraordinary estate is a timeless masterpiece inside and out, seamlessly blending historic charm with modern refinement.

8 Stonegate Lane, Old Brookville

$4,399,000

5 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 987442 MLS

Set within the rarefied landscape of Old Brookville, this striking Mid-Century Modern residence is a study in architectural drama and refined design. Celebrated in Luxe Interiors + Design at the time of its transformation, the home reflects the visionary collaboration between its owners and the acclaimed firm Garcia/Maldonado, Inc.. The result is a masterwork where every line, material, and proportion has been considered with uncompromising precision. A rich palette of exotic woods—mahogany, oak, and birch—anchors the interiors with warmth and texture, while the architecture itself unfolds with quiet grandeur. The great room is nothing short of breathtaking: a soaring vaulted ceiling, commanding fireplace, and an expansive wall of glass dissolve the boundary between indoors and out, flooding the space with natural light and framing the surrounding landscape as living art. An elegant dining room overlooks the property and is the perfect venue for entertaining. At the heart of the home, the kitchen is both generous and inviting—designed for gathering and everyday luxury—with a substantial center island, sunlit breakfast room, and seamless connection to an open den. A separate media room, complete with a built-in bar and sliding doors, offers the flexibility for both intimate evenings and vibrant entertaining. The first-floor primary suite is a private sanctuary, opening directly to the grounds and featuring its own fireplace. A dramatic staircase leads to a secluded study—an architectural moment that elevates both function and form. The suite is further enhanced by a bespoke fitted closet room and a spa-like bath, exquisitely detailed in teak wood to evoke a sense of serenity, complete with dual vanities, a soaking tub, and a separate glass-enclosed shower. Upstairs, three oversized ensuite bedrooms, each with their own bath are complemented by an open lounge, creating a natural gathering space bathed in light. The lower level extends the lifestyle with a recreation room, additional den, and dedicated gym. Set across three exquisitely landscaped acres, the property evokes a private country club experience: a newly crafted Ipe deck, sparkling in-ground pool, Har-tru tennis court, and cabana complete this exceptional offering—where architecture and setting exist in perfect harmony.

93 Hoaglands Lane, Old Brookville

$6,450,000

7 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 991638 MLS

Set behind private gates in the prestigious Estates at Greenfield, this stately brick Georgian Colonial is perfectly positioned on three + magnificently landscaped acres, offering an exceptional blend of timeless architecture and resort-style living. A gracious approach leads to a generous courtyard, creating a striking first impression and a true sense of arrival. Inside, a dramatic two-story center hall marble foyer showcases a sweeping wrought iron circular staircase and exquisite, detailed millwork that sets the tone for the home’s refined interiors. The formal living room is both elegant and inviting, complete with a custom built-in bar and hardwood floors while the generous dining room is perfectly suited for grand entertaining. A warm and inviting den with a fireplace sits just off the chef’s kitchen and sunlit breakfast nook, creating an ideal flow for everyday living. A richly appointed home office features its own fireplace, custom built-in shelving, and a convenient half bath. The first floor is further enhanced by a private ensuite bedroom, perfect for guests or extended family. The second level offers a luxurious primary en-suite retreat with a fireplace, a gracious sitting room, and multiple custom-fitted closets. The spa-like marble bathroom adds to the sense of indulgence. Four additional ensuite bedrooms provide comfort and privacy, while a fabulous bonus room offers flexibility as a second den, media lounge, or computer room. The lower level has been thoughtfully designed for recreation and relaxation, featuring a game room, media area, gym, and abundant storage. Outdoors, the property is truly extraordinary—lush, expansive, and beautifully curated with mature specimen trees that provide both privacy and natural beauty. Designed for both relaxation and recreation, the grounds include a sparkling pool and hot tub, a full-service cabana, and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen ideal for seamless entertaining. A sports court and playground complete this exceptional offering. The property is simply divine—an all-encompassing retreat in The Estates at Greenfield, where every amenity has been thoughtfully curated, offering a lifestyle so complete there is truly no reason to ever leave home.

6 Evergreen Way, Old Brookville

$3,899,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 957864 MLS

Nestled in the heart of Old Brookville, this private oasis offers the perfect blend of luxury, tranquility, and modern living. Set on a sprawling, flat 3.2 -acre lot within the prestigious North Shore School District, this property feels like your own year-round retreat. As you approach via the picturesque private driveway, you're greeted by lush, mature landscaping that ensures complete seclusion. The property boasts a sparkling gunite saltwater pool with a chic pool house, a clay tennis court, and plenty of open space to enjoy outdoor living at its finest. Step inside this contemporary gem, and you'll find a thoughtfully designed floor plan that caters to comfort and style. The main level features a stunning primary ensuite with its own private deck—your perfect sanctuary for morning coffee or evening relaxation. The home has been meticulously updated with hardy plank siding, new windows, a modern A/C system, and a hot water heater. Simply move in and make it your own! Whether you're lounging by the pool, hosting friends on the tennis court, or unwinding in your serene retreat, this home truly offers a vacation lifestyle all year long. Don’t miss your chance to experience the ultimate in privacy and luxury living.

91 Hoaglands Lane, Old Brookville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.